When the province of Ontario announced three years ago it was offering up cash to school boards to improve security and safety, the reaction was mixed. Parents were concerned their facilities would become locked down fortresses.
By Jennifer Brown
The funding was made available to strengthen the Safe Schools Act,
which gives a school principal the right and authority to refuse entry
of any person and they can ask someone to leave if they believe the
person poses a danger. That provision made it became important for
schools to control access to their facilities.
However, there were some schools in Ontario where the main office was not in view of the main entrance.
The province would provide funding to problem-prone schools, up to
$4,000 per school. Using that money, the school board could install a
video camera and voice intercom buzzer system so that someone in the
office could see and hear who was at the door and let them in. The
front doors had to remain locked at all times if a school were to be
eligible for the funding. It became a controversial issue in some
Some regions, however, like the Niagara Catholic District School board,
based in Welland, Ont., saw it as an opportunity to improve safety for
students and took advantage of the funding.
“We had 26 schools and they all wanted to go this way, and we got the
funding and started installing those systems,” says James Woods,
Controller of Plant Services with the Niagara Catholic District School
“When we first started out with this locking the doors idea the parents
thought we were locking them out of the school, but security has always
been an issue and we’re always concerned about the safety of the
children left in our care,” says Woods. “If somebody comes in, they’re
supposed to report to the office; they’re supposed to have visitor
badge if they are allowed to go further into the school.”
With intruder incidents happening in other districts, opinions on the
matter started to change and soon, Woods says, parents were asking,
“Can you do our school next?”
Today, all 53 elementary schools in the NCDSB and the board office are
equipped with camera and intercom systems at the entry point and have
Keyscan access control systems integrated with that at a cost of about
To guard against vandalism, the card readers were mounted behind
security glass and the wires run inside the door mullion, eliminating
the need for conduit or exposed wiring chases.
The security upgrade began two years ago, with half the schools done in 2006/2007 and the remaining half in 2007/2008.
Every school has an IP camera on the front door and select schools have
a digital video recorder and other cameras around the property.
Working with Kitchener-Waterloo, Ont.-based Bulldog Fire & Security, the board now has a networked camera and access control system.
“The system includes a camera that goes on our network and the voice
intercom is on our telephone network. Any computer in the building can
see the picture of who is at the school and any phone can talk to them
and you can release a door by pushing a button on a telephone,” says
There doesn’t have to be a secretary sitting in the office with a view
of the monitor; it can be the principal at their desk or in the
“You can always check the door and alleviate the parents concerns that
they would be at the front door with no one answering,” says Woods.
The original access control system NCDSB deployed was implemented by
another company, but the schools decided they didn’t want the access
control software residing on their PCs.
“It wasn’t as versatile because it was limited to one or two PCs and
the schools change their PCs quite often and they didn’t want the
software to be loaded on them, so we went with a browser-based system
with a Sony camera so anyone with the IP address could see the front
door camera,” says Joe McCann, regional sales manager of Bulldog
Fire & Security.
The board’s coordinator of protective systems in charge of security and
fire alarm systems, Sergio Cassolato, can also control the doors
“He doesn’t even have to take off his slippers,” Woods says.
The board can also go into lockdown from the board office or from the site.
With so many doors in a school, it’s virtually impossible to totally
control access, and in some cases parents are often walking into a
child’s classroom to pick them up.
“It was becoming a problem for some of the schools. Mostly we didn’t
know at any one time who was in the school. So we started locking all
the exterior doors except for the main door. Then (Education Minister)
Gerard Kennedy made the announcement they wanted better control of the
main access,” says Woods.
Installing a card access system was a natural outcome of needing a
better way to control the entrances, says Woods. “With card access, you
can control access by giving anyone access at any particular time or
building,” says Woods.
After years of dealing with key control problems the board decided to
put everything on card access. “We always had issues with keys — one
would go lost and you’d have to change all the locks and it could be
duplicated or passed between person to person.”
The NCDSB plans to continue to roll out card access at its other high
schools, focusing on making all exterior doors controllable and
specialty classrooms, such as chemistry labs and mechanical shops.
Having rolled out the system to all the board’s elementary schools,
Woods says public opinion has changed dramatically from when the Safe
Schools Act funding was first announced by the province three years ago.